Skip to main content

MN 8 Sujato encouraging us to extinguish others if we become an arahant?

 

MN 8: Sallekhasutta—Bhikkhu Sujato (suttacentral.net)


Truly, Cunda, if you’re sinking down in the mud you can’t pull out someone else who is also sinking down in the mud.So vata, cunda, attanā palipapalipanno paraṁ palipapalipannaṁ uddharissatīti netaṁ ṭhānaṁ vijjati.But if you’re not sinking down in the mud you can pull out someone else who is sinking down in the mud.So vata, cunda, attanā apalipapalipanno paraṁ palipapalipannaṁ uddharissatīti ṭhānametaṁ vijjati.Truly, if you’re not tamed, trained, and extinguished you can’t tame, train, and extinguish someone else.So vata, cunda, attanā adanto avinīto aparinibbuto paraṁ damessati vinessati parinibbāpessatīti netaṁ ṭhānaṁ vijjati.But if you’re tamed, trained, and extinguished you can tame, train, and extinguish someone else.So vata, cunda, attanā danto vinīto parinibbuto paraṁ damessati vinessati parinibbāpessatīti ṭhānametaṁ vijjati.


frankk comment:

Nirvana means 'extinguished', like a fire going out, or thirst being extinguished.

Sujato's reason for literal translation of nirvana = extinguishment, is that most people have unhealthy metaphysical wrong views about 'nirvana'.

He has a point. However.

While I often do like literal translations, and as far as I can tell he's been very consistent with 'extinguish' everywhere in his suttas, this translation choice has two major problems.

1. In many suttas, most readers don't realize 'extinguish' is referring to a special property of 'nirvana', freedom from all suffering forever, that the sutta has just announced the accomplishment of the ultimate goal.

2. As in this sutta MN 8 passage shows, it reads like a violent command to kill others. In other suttas, it could sound like suicide to oneself. 


My translation choice is to leave Nirvana untranslated


So vata, cunda, attanā adanto avinīto aparinibbuto paraṃ damessati vinessati parinibbāpessatīti netaṃ ṭhānaṃ vijjati.
Truly, if you’re not tamed, trained, and nirvana'd you can’t tame, train, and nirvanify someone else.
So vata, cunda, attanā danto vinīto parinibbuto paraṃ damessati vinessati parinibbāpessatīti ṭhānametaṃ vijjati.
But if you’re tamed, trained, and nirvana'd you can tame, train, and nirvanify someone else.
Evameva kho, cunda, vihiṃsakassa purisapuggalassa avihiṃsā hoti parinibbānāya, pāṇātipātissa purisapuggalassa pāṇātipātā veramaṇī hoti parinibbānāya.
In the same way, a cruel individual nirvanifyes it by not being cruel. An individual who kills nirvanifyes it by not killing. …


 What do you think?

Does that lead to wrong metaphysical ideas about nirvana that Sujato is worried about? 

I don't say Sujato's translation is wrong, but I find it problematic.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Advice to younger meditators on jhāna, sex, porn, masturbation

Someone asked: Is porn considered harmful sexual.activity? I don't have a sex life because I don't have a partner and I don't wish to engage in casual sex so I use porn to quench the biological urge to orgasm. I can't see that's it's harmful because nobody is being forced into it. The actors are all paid well and claim to enjoy it etc. The only harm I can see is that it's so accessible these days on smart devices and so children may access it but I believe that this is the parents responsibility to not allow unsupervised use of devices etc. Views? Frankk response: In another thread, you asked about pleasant sensations and jhāna.  I'm guessing you're young, so here's some important advice you won't get from suttas   if you're serious about jhāna.  (since monastics are already celibate by rule)   If you want to attain stable and higher jhānas,   celibacy and noble silence to the best of your ability are the feedstock and prerequiste to tha...
Post a Comment
Read more

SN 48.40 Ven. Thanissaro comments on Ven. Sunyo's analysis

This was Ven. Sunyo's analysis of SN 48.40: https://notesonthedhamma.blogspot.com/2024/05/exciting-news-honest-ebt-scholars-like.html And here is Ven. Thanissaro's response to that analysis: I think there’s a better way to tackle the issue of SN 48:40 than by appealing to the oldest layers of commentarial literature. That way is to point out that SN 48:40, as we have it, doesn’t pass the test in DN 16 for determining what’s genuine Dhamma and what’s not. There the standard is, not the authority of the person who’s claiming to report the Buddha’s teachings, but whether the teachings he’s reporting are actually in accordance with the principles of the Dhamma that you know. So the simple fact that those who have passed the Buddha’s teachings down to us say that a particular passage is what the Buddha actually taught is not sufficient grounds for accepting it. In the case of the jhānas—the point at issue here— we have to take as our guide the standard formula for the jhānas, a...
Post a Comment
Read more

1min. video: Dalai Lama kissing boy and asking him to suck his tongue

To give more context, this is a public event,  * everyone knows cameras are rolling  *  it's a room full of children * the boy's mom is standing off camera a few feet away watching all of this * the boy initiated contact, he had already had a hug with Dalai Lama earlier and then asked Dalai Lama for another hug which triggered this segment  17 min. video showing what happened before that 1 min. clip and after, with some explanation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bT0qey5Ts78 16min talk from Ajahn Acalo with his thoughts on Dalai Lama kissing boy, relevance to Bhikkhu monastic code, sexual predators in religion in general, and how celibate monastics deal with sexual energy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uK2m0TcUib0 The child's comments about the incident in a filmed interview later https://www.marca.com/en/lifestyle/world-news/2023/04/18/643eba5d46163ffc078b457c.html The child: It's a great experience It was amazing to meet His Holiness and I think it's a great ex...
Post a Comment
Read more