mikenz66 wrote: ↑Sun Oct 15, 2023 10:55 amHi Emptyset,
This is a frequently-argued question and it is unfortunate that is is sometimes expressed as "sutta vs visuddhimagga".
Several discussions of how "absorbed" the jhana that the Buddha taught, based on early texts, are linked by Ven Dhammanando's post here: viewtopic.php?p=560317#p560317
Deja Vu. Mike, are you a real person, or an AI bot spamming fake news/misinformation on jhāna whenever the topic comes up? We've had this exact same discussion many times now. I've shown in detail how Analayo's understanding of jhāna in his book you quoted is based on fallacious reasoning here: https://lucid24.org/sted/8aam/8samadhi/ ... index.html (in short, Analayo uses circular reasoning. Like saying the Bible is true because God said so in the bible.)
The threads you link from Ven. Dhammando are not only outdated, but biased with proponents of the Vism. redefinition of jhāna who cherry pick a handful of passages and ignoring the bulk of sutta passages that contradict them.
I have comprehensive research on every single instance of vitakka in the suttas here: https://lucid24.org/sted/8aam/8samadhi/ ... index.html which show that in first jhāna they must be linguistic, verbal, communicable language.
All the suttas on hearing sounds (and mentally processing them) is here: https://lucid24.org/tped/s/samadhi/smd247/index.html#5 Just reading one sutta alone, DN 21, which explicitly states the Buddha being interrupted while in 'jhāna' by a musician singing, is enough to show the 'sutta jhāna' and Vism.'s redefined "jhāna" are qualitatively completely different animals. https://lucid24.org/dn/main/dn21/index.html#tophead I annotate exactly where the jhāna and hearing are happening in DN 21 so even Mike can't miss it.
And the collection of sutta passages analyzed here show the Buddha's jhāna can not be a frozen disembodied stupor as Vism. redefines it. https://lucid24.org/tped/s/samadhi/smd2 ... ml#tophead 24/7 samādhi 1 – Book 1: 4 Jhānas ≈ 4 Satipaṭṭhāna 24/7 samādhi 2 – Book 2: Jhāna + samādhi in all 4 postures 24/7 samādhi 3 – Book 3: Samādhi & jhāna all the time 24/7 24/7 samādhi 4 – Book 4: Upasampajja Viharati: Attains and lives doing Jhāna samādhi 24/7 samādhi 5 – Book 5: You can hear sounds in all 4 jhānas, not just the first. Which samādhis are silent? 24/7 samādhi 6 – Book 6: Rūpa is not a-rūpa. Duh! 🛇 4 jhānas are not a-rūpa
Bhante Gunaratana's current views on jhāna
Bhante Gunaratana had incorrect views based on Vism., but his phd thesis containing that is still widely circulated. 30 years later, he published a new book with his new views.
Do you think it's proper to keep sharing links to old outdated views abandoned by people without also sharing their updated one?
≈ 4 Satipaṭṭhāna
sounds in all 4 jhānas, not just the first. Which samādhis are silent?
4 jhānas are not a-rūpa
Comments
Post a Comment