Tuesday, March 29, 2022

AN 3.101 gold washer, ☸Dhamma-vitakka💭 in this context defintely is the vitakka of first jhāna

 These are all the occurrences of 'Dhamma vitakka' in the suttas. 

AN 8.30 is especially explicit, unambiguous, unequivocal in giving eight examples of linguistic, verbal thoughts, right before using the same word, vitakka, to describe standard formula for first jhāna.

Because AN 3.101 doesn't explicitly call out which jhānas the samādhi is referring to, Sujato tries to use AN 3.101 in support of his erroneous interpretation of vitakka in first jhāna being non linguistic, non verbal, non-thought even.

But AN 8.30 makes it unequivocal that first jhāna is using a verbal vitakka. 


4👑☸ → EBpedia📚 → ☸Dhamma-vitakka💭 

(KN Snp 5.14 is 'Dhamma-takka' in verse, which often for meter reasons, will use variations on standard terms, for example 'pekkhamano' and 'avekkhanta' are obviously 'upekkha' in Snp 5 context).



No comments:

Post a Comment